Modern Semi-Auto Rifles Do Deliver Long-Range Accuracy
by Will Cox
Opportunities for long-range shooting have improved dramatically
in my part of North Texas over the past couple of years with the
opening of the Tac Pro Shooting Center (35100 N. State Hwy. 108,
Dept. GWK, Mingus, TX 76463; phone: 254-968-3112; on-line: www.tacproshooting-center.com)
on the prairie west of Fort Worth. Tac Pro, under the direction
of Bill Davison, a British expatriate formerly with the Special
Boat Service, offers training in the use of small arms and also
opens it's ranges to the public. One of these is a 1,000-yard
rifle range.
I've been shooting and hunting with rifles for a long time and
have even been fortunate enough to have had some formal training
in the use of the tactical carbine and Scout Rifle at Thunder
Ranch and Gunsite. My opportunities for true long-range precision
shooting, however, have been pretty much limited to the occasional
"Hail Mary" type shot taken just for fun at a rock or
other inanimate object during treks to the back country; once
or twice I've even managed to connect.
I've been hunting deer in Texas all of my life, but nearly every
shot has been less than 200 yards, with the vast majority probably
closer to 100. The range at Tac Pro, while a bit daunting to a
non-sniper like myself, was a challenge I decided I should try.
But I needed a rifle.
I already owned several nice hunting rifles, including
my beloved Gunsite Scout, but for target shooting out past 300
yards, something more on the order of a true precision rifle seemed
called for. This also provided an excuse to try out a gun I've
had my eye on for a while now. The AR-15 has been one of my favorite
rifles for a long time and I currently own four, the most recent
acquisition being a neat little ArmaLite carbine.
Perusing the ArmaLite catalog prior to the carbine's purchase
had revealed several rifles chambered in .308 rather than .223.
One, the AR-10T, features a free-floating stainless 24-inch heavy
barrel and a two-stage match trigger. The receiver is of the "flat
top" or Picatinny rail variety, providing a solid base for
mounting optics. I had wanted to shoot one of these rifles since
first seeing it in the catalog and now I had a proper place.
But the question was: Would a gas gun be accurate enough for true
long-range work? I was about to find out. An order was placed
with ArmaLite.
The Past
The AR-10 rifle was first produced in 1955 by the original ArmaLite company when it was still a division of the Fairchild Engine and Airplane Corporation. This was during the period in which the Army was seeking a replacement for the Garand, considering both the T-44 (M-14) and the T-48 (a version of the FN-FAL).
With the AR-10, ArmaLite hoped to knock them out of the running.
That didn't happen, of course, and the rest is the history of
the M-14. The AR-10 was licensed to the Dutch Arsenal, Artellerie
Inrichtengen, but since sales languished, it soon fell into small
arms limbo.
Fast forward to 1995 when Mark Westrom, owner of Eagle Arms, purchased
the rights to the ArmaLite trademark and decided to name his new
.308 rifle the AR-10. The AR-10T is one of several members of
this .308 family.
First Impressions
Ten days after placing the order I had my rifle. Initial
inspection showed everything to be as expected. Other than size
and the match trigger mechanism, the only difference between the
AR-10T and the AR-15 is a firing pin spring.
The manual states that it is provided to prevent primer dents
when closing the bolt and possible slam fires. I've never experienced
one with an AR-15, but perhaps with the heavier firing pin of
the AR-10 rifles it's a good idea. In any event it obviously works
well and I'm happy to report there were no slam fires.
The only area of concern was the trigger. It was beautiful, breaking
at four pounds after initial take up with only a small amount
of creep, which the owner's manual correctly advised would reduce
to an acceptable level with use. It felt pretty good to me out
of the box so why was I concerned?
I've known several AR-type rifles over the years with "trigger
jobs" and "custom match triggers" and most of them
have doubled, or worse, eventually. Frankly, I was worried that
I would have the same problem, but I shouldn't have been concerned.
During the course of the test, I would fire over 500 rounds and
I had to press the trigger every time.
Setting the AR-10T up for the range was a simple task. After inspection
and cleaning, all that was left was to mount the 2.5-10xI.O.R.
Voldada tactical scope in the supplied mount and attach my Turner
sling. The next day I was off to a nearby range for sighting in
the scope and breaking in the barrel.
I bore-sighted the Voldada, loaded a 10-round magazine (two are
supplied) with Remington's inexpensive ball ammo, and was immediately
on paper at 50 yards. ArmaLite provides an instruction sheet with
a very detailed prescription for the break-in of the triple-lapped
stainless barrel.
The instructions probably work very well, though I can't say for
sure as I had left the sheet at home. Not wanting to waste a trip
I decided to use a method that has worked well for me in the past
where the barrel is cleaned after every shot three times, after
every two shots 10 times, and after every three shots five times.
By the end of this process I had moved to the 100-yard bench and
had begun to pay attention to group size. They ran about 1-1/2
inches which is very good for ball ammo. Next I tried some of
the excellent Hornady 168-grain AMAX match stuff. Three 5-round
groups were between 5/8- and 3/4-inch center-to-center. Yes! I
wanted to keep shooting but the break-in had eaten up most of
the afternoon. Like any AR, you have to field strip it to clean
the barrel from the breach which is fairly time consuming.
Getting Familiar
On subsequent range trips over the following weeks
I switched to the 200-yard bench and tried some Cor-Bon match
rounds as well as some Black Hills moly-coated ammo to determine
if the accuracy with the Hornady could be duplicated. Nearly!
It was a matter of consistency. Both would group into one minute-of-angle
(MOA) at 200 yards regularly and occasionally 3/4 of an inch,
but the Hornady fodder would do -inch any time and often a bit
less in this particular rifle.
Here I should pause for a disclaimer. I suspect that with the
Hornady ammo this rifle might be capable of 1/2 MOA in the proper
hands. A shooter with superior bench rest technique than myself,
using more sophisticated equipment, could likely do better. But
I was still mightily impressed. Anytime I can get 3/4 MOA at 200
yards with an out-of-the-box semi-auto rifle using factory ammo,
I call it success.
During these same weeks I had another pleasant surprise. My supply
of Remington ball had been exhausted by barrel break-in and plinking.
Not wanting to burn up all my match stuff just yet, I tried some
inexpensive Portuguese surplus ammo I had on hand. One-and-one-quarter
to 1-and-one-half MOA at 200. Cool!
There was a three-gun match coming up at Tac Pro and I made the
decision to use the AR-10T for the rifle stages. My buddy, Skip,
and I shared the rifle and were the only ones in our squad to
hit three steel prairie dog silhouettes at 200 yards with only
four shots each from a hastily assumed field position. (Davison
called them "assault prairie dogs" as this was a tactical
match after all.) We saw other shooters blow as many as 25 rounds
before dispatching these same three "prairie dogs."
Long Distance
On several subsequent trips to Tac Pro I shot the AR-10T out to 500 yards. My favorite target was a steel humanoid silhouette with a hinged flapper in the chest area. This flapper was about 8 inches square and would move to the rear and then reset itself after each impact. From 300 yards it didn't stand a chance. From a prone or cross-legged seated position I could hit the flapper virtually every time.
The same target at 500 yards proved more of a challenge, but only
slightly. From a seated position, due to my inability to hold
well enough, I might only manage to hit the flapper three or four
times out of 10. From a rock-solid prone though, I could pretty
much tag it at will. The heavy 24-inch barrel "hangs"
well, providing stability, and the great trigger (which had lost
its creep by now) made breaking the shot without disturbing the
sight picture an easy task. Also I was glad to have the Turner
sling to wrap myself into. The nylon unit that comes with the
gun is really more of a carrying strap than a shooting aid.
Five hundred yards was the maximum distance from which
I fired the AR-10T as I was unable to attend the orientation class
that Davison mandates to shoot further. Sooner or later I will
have the opportunity to do so and hopefully report on the results.
At the Bench
By now I had pretty much exhausted all the factory match ammo I had on hand and since it goes for about a buck a round I decided it was time to spend some time at the loading bench. Could I handload rounds that would at least come close to the wonderful accuracy I was seeing with the Hornady ammo? The answer turned out to be yes, and thanks to the folks at Redding, it was easy.
Redding offers a full-length sizing die with removable bushings
which size the neck and are available in .001-inch increments.
The procedure is to measure the neck of a loaded round of the
brand and lot of brass that is to be used and then insert a bushing
which is .002 or .003 smaller into the die. This will result in
a proper press fit for the bullet of .001-.002. With the die properly
adjusted these bushings will self-center on the neck and improve
concentricity. The result is the elimination of the variation
in mass-produced dies.
Use of the Redding Competition Shell Holders also made achieving
proper headspace easy. Available in sets of five from plus .002-.010,
these shell holders allow setting correct headspace with the shell
holder against the bottom of the die which provides a more precise
alignment.
Seating of the 168-grain Sierra Match Kings was accomplished with
the Redding Competition Seating Die. Not only is seating depth
adjustable to within .001 by virtue of a micrometer, but correct
bullet alignment is assured by an internal sliding sleeve which
is independent of the depth stop and allows the bullet to align
itself before meeting firm resistance.
I had some Norma brass that was consistent enough in weight and
neck wall thickness that I decided to forego neck turning. Measuring
the necks of loaded rounds showed a dimension of .335 so I used
bushings that were .333 and .332. Basic reloading techniques and
a recipe of 40.8 grains of 3031 with Federal Match primers under
the Match Kings resulted in .95 MOA at 200 yards with the first
batch. Sweet!
I could determine no difference in group size between rounds loaded
with the .332 and the .333 bushings. Additional experimentation
would almost certainly shrink groups down to the size of the Hornady
ammo. I suspect that if I had had a supply of the AMAX bullets
on hand my handloads would have done even better as this particular
rifle just liked that bullet.
A Final Test
By this time I had had the rifle for several months and fired over 500 rounds through it-both off the bench and at Tac Pro. What else could I do for a thorough field test? Take it to the field of course. Thanksgiving was approaching and with it my annual deer hunt at Brinlee Ranch in Pecos County, TX. A hunt in this rough country will quickly reveal any weaknesses in guns, equipment and hunters.
Several days of hiking, climbing, and stand hunting proved the
ArmaLite up to the task. When the proper time came, the AR-10T
performed perfectly and collected a nice eight-pointer using Remington's
Premier Boat Tail 165-grain softpoint which dropped the buck in
his tracks.
I'd like to say that the shot was 325 yards across a canyon requiring
every bit of the AR-10T's phenomenal accuracy. I'd like to, but
I'd be lying as it was only 115 yards. However, it was early morning
and the sun wasn't up yet but the light gathering capabilities
of the Voldada glass made it easy. This Romanian-made sight appears
to offer the optical quality of more famous European scopes at
a much more reasonable price.
According to those who know about such things, the AR-10T should
also make for an ideal sniper rifle. I recently visited with a
friend in the SEAL Teams who had just completed the SEAL Sniper
Course. One of the rifles he was issued was a .308 AR-style so
apparently the SEALs are okay with the concept of a semi-auto
sniper rifle. That's good enough for me. My friend stated that
the AR was his favorite of all the rifles (Remington bolt-actions,
M21's, etc.) he was issued in the course and now refers to it
as his "war gun."
In a recent article in Soldier of Fortune on civilian volunteer
police snipers in Israel (They really have those!), the author
reported on using an ArmaLite AR-10T to good effect in that troubled
land. Before deploying one as a true tactical rifle though, I
would want to somehow darken the bright stainless barrel to avoid
detection.
The Last Word
Is there anything to criticize with this gun? I'm having trouble. At 43.5 inches it's a little long for heavy brush and quick snap shots but that's the price to be paid for the great "hang" of the 24-inch barrel. Also the weight, 10.5 pounds without scope, will be objectionable to some for a hunting rifle although it didn't bother me much.
I did have a couple of inconsequential hiccups which I nevertheless
feel compelled to report. One was a failure to feed the Remington
softpointed hunting ammo. This rifle was designed for full metal
jacketed match bullets so it's really not fair to fault it for
not feeding softpoints. If that is a requirement, some careful
polishing by a good gunsmith should fix the problem. Also there
was one failure to fire with the Portuguese surplus ammo but I
didn't sweat it. The dent in the primer looked fine and it was
foreign surplus after all.
There really isn't anything to complain about with the AR-10T.
It does everything it was designed to do and it looks good doing
it.
For more information, contact: ArmaLite Inc., PO Box 299, Dept.
GWK, Geneseo, IL 61254; phone: 309-944-6939; fax: 309-944-6949;
on-line: www.armalite.com.